The Armed Forces Tribunal (AFT) has directed the Army to step up the pay of a retired Lieutenant General who received less than a junior officer of the same rank. The Tribunal said that placement in different pay levels could not, on its own, settle the question of an established pay anomaly between senior and junior officers holding the same rank.
Pay disparity after the Seventh Pay Commission
In an order dated November 13, a Bench comprising Justice Anu Malhotra and Administrative Member Rasika Chaube considered the Army’s arrangement under which Lieutenant Generals may be placed in different pay scales according to seniority. It rejected the view that officers could be treated as holding the same rank for service and duties but as incomparable when examining the pay difference.
The applicant was commissioned into the Corps of Signals in December 1977 and retired in July 2016. After being promoted to Lieutenant General in October 2012, he was placed in the Higher Administrative Grade (HAG), with monthly pay of ₹75,000. He moved to the Higher Administrative Grade-Plus (HAG-Plus) scale in January 2014, and his pay was revised to ₹80,000.
When the Seventh Central Pay Commission recommendations took effect on January 1, 2016, his pay was fixed at ₹2,17,900. He later found that a junior officer from the same Corps, promoted to Lieutenant General in July 2016, had pay fixed at ₹2,24,100 in HAG. The senior officer therefore drew less despite his seniority and placement in HAG-Plus.
Arguments over the applicable rules
The officer challenged the fixation under Rule 7 of the Army Officers Pay Rules, 2017. His counsel, retired Colonel Indra Sen Singh, argued that the rule required a senior officer’s pay to be stepped up when a junior promoted on or after January 1, 2016, received more than a senior promoted before that date.
Counsel also submitted that the lower pay had affected the applicant’s retirement benefits: his pension was based on ₹2,17,900, with a consequential effect on his pensionary entitlements. The applicant argued that the disparity was arbitrary and discriminatory and breached the constitutional guarantee of equality and the principle of equal pay for equal work.
The Army opposed the application, saying HAG and HAG-Plus were distinct pay levels for pay fixation and promotion. Since the applicant was in HAG-Plus and his junior was in HAG, the Army argued, the conditions for stepping up pay under Rule 7 were not met.
The Principal Controller of Defence Accounts also declined the request, stating that the statutory conditions had not been satisfied. The authorities relied on the rules’ definitions identifying HAG as Level 15 and HAG-Plus as Level 16 in the Pay Matrix. Government counsel further argued that there was no direct recruitment to either grade and that placing one-third of Lieutenant Generals in HAG-Plus on the basis of seniority did not remove the distinction between the two levels.
Tribunal’s reasoning and direction
The Tribunal noted that the applicant was drawing ₹2,17,900 in January 2016, while his junior was then drawing ₹2,11,800 as a Major General. After the junior’s promotion to Lieutenant General in July 2016, his pay was fixed at ₹2,24,100, leaving him on a higher salary than the applicant until the latter’s retirement.
The Bench acknowledged that HAG and HAG-Plus are separate Pay Matrix levels, but observed that HAG-Plus is an upgradation granted to one-third of senior officers, not a separate promotion. The two grades, it said, are different financial placements within the same military rank. Treating them as wholly unrelated when considering the pay anomaly between two Lieutenant Generals would be artificial.
The Tribunal also referred to Rule 16 of the Army Officers Pay Rules, 2017, which allows the rules to be relaxed in appropriate cases where their strict application causes undue hardship. It directed the Army to step up the retired officer’s pay, finding that the difference between HAG and HAG-Plus could not automatically deny relief when a senior officer received less than a junior of the same rank. The ruling addresses the pay anomaly and its stated impact on the officer’s retirement benefits.

